The boutique hotel industry is facing a technology decision crisis that is stalling independent operators and potentially pushing them toward franchise models, according to Jennifer Barnwell, Senior Vice President of Asset Management at Pebblebrook Hotel Trust and co-founder of Curator Hotel & Resort Collection, a platform for independent boutique hotels.
“In the independent boutique space, you know, I think it’s good. Some people can be like paralyzing, there’s a million choices,” Barnwell said, highlighting a challenge that sets independent hotels apart from branded ones. While franchise hotels have technology decisions made at the corporate level, independent operators must sift through a crowded field of solutions.
For a basic property management system alone, Barnwell notes there are “probably 20 or 30 choices.” Central reservation systems offer around 10 options, revenue management systems present 15 to 20, and restaurant point-of-sale systems add another 15. “So, you know, in the independent boutique space there’s obviously a set list of things that you need to operate. But then every choice, there’s so many choices within that choice, and then they stack upon each other,” she said.
The challenge goes beyond selecting individual technologies. These systems must integrate, increasing complexity as every decision affects the next. Barnwell noted that while some companies claim to offer comprehensive solutions, “you’re not really sure, like, do they do everything really well, or do they just do one thing and then they bought some others so that they can say they have everything under their one umbrella.”
This level of decision fatigue is more than an inconvenience—it puts independent hotels at a disadvantage. “There’s just so many so much noise, like there’s so many choices,” Barnwell emphasized, describing how the abundance of options leads to analysis paralysis rather than a competitive edge.
The problem grows as hotels look to adopt new technologies. Barnwell’s team evaluates new platforms weekly, from AI voice agents to robotics, but admits, “We can’t adopt it all. It’s not, you know, it doesn’t feel right to keep layering more and more and more on top of everything.”
This technology conundrum reflects a broader industry issue. As major hotel brands consolidate and standardize, independent operators face increasingly difficult decisions about balancing autonomy with the need for advanced capabilities. For boutique hotels, the freedom to choose their own tech stack has become a significant operational challenge.
This situation suggests that independent hotels will need new ways to make technology decisions, such as advisory services, peer networks, or platforms that aggregate buying power without reducing flexibility. Otherwise, more operators may opt for the simplicity of franchise requirements over the complexity of managing technology independently.
